THE ROLE OF FAMILY GOVERNANCE BEYOND FINANCIAL RATIOS: AN INTEGRATED PERSPECTIVE ON FAMILY FIRMS’ SURVIVAL
Abstract
In the years following the economic and financial crisis, Italy, where most firms are family-owned, has seen the demise of more companies than any other country. To avoid a similar disaster in the future, it is important to understand which determinants influence firms’ survival. Stemming from financial and family business literature, this paper investigates the role of financial ratios and family corporate governance in predicting family firms’ survival probability. To obtain empirical evidence, it performs a mediating regression analysis using a sample of 273 Italian family firms. The main findings show that family ownership concentration and the presence of a family CEO increase firms’ survival probability, while a high number of family members involved in the firm and the co-presence of more generations hinder it.
References
- 2011] Business strategy and competitive advantage in family businesses in Ghana: The role of social networking relationships, Journal of developmental entrepreneurship, XVI, 103–126. Link, Google Scholar [
- 2014] Governance issues in family businesses, International Journal of Economics, Commerce and Management II, 1–28. Google Scholar [
- 2015] Pengaruh struktur aktiva, profitabilitas dan ukuran perusahaan terhadap struktur modal, Journal Ilmu dan Riset Manajemen IV, 8. Google Scholar [
- 2008] The impact of family control on the performance and financial characteristics of family versus nonfamily businesses in Japan: A matched-pair investigation, Family Business Review XXI, 315–330. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- 1968] Financial ratios, discriminant analysis and the prediction of corporate bankruptcy, The Journal of Finance, XXIII, 589–609. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- 2010] Corporate Financial Distress and Bankruptcy: Predict and Avoid Bankruptcy, Analyze and Invest in Distressed Debt. USA: John Wiley and Sons. Google Scholar [
- 2007] Modelling credit risk for SMEs: Evidence from the U.S. Market, ABACUS XLIII, 332–357. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- 2003] Founding family ownership and the agency cost of debt, Journal of Financial Economics LXVIII, 263–285. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- 2010] Outsiders on the board of directors and firm performance: Evidence from Spanish non-listed family firms, Journal of Family Business Strategy I, 236–245. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- 2010] The benefits of family ownership, control and management on financial performance of firms, Indiana University-Bloomington School of Public & Environmental Affairs Research Paper II, 189–211. Google Scholar [
- 2018] Structural aspects of corporate governance and family firm performance: A systematic review, Journal of Family Business Management III, 150–165. Google Scholar [
- 2011] Boards of directors in family businesses: A literature review and research agenda, International Journal of Management Reviews XIII, 134–152. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- 1986] The moderator-mediator variable distinction in social psychological research: Conceptual, strategic, and statistical considerations, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, LI, 1173–1182. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- 2006] The effect of family control on firm value and performance: Evidence from continental Europe, European Financial Management XII, 689–723. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- 2012] Pecking-Order or static trade-off theory in family firms? Evidence from Belgium, International Business Research V, 1. Google Scholar [
- 1966] Financial ratios as predictors of failure, Journal of Accounting Research IV, 71–111. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- 2012] Socioemotional wealth in family firms: Theoretical dimensions, assessment approaches, and agenda for future research, Family Business Review XXV, 258–279. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- 2006] The role of family in family firms, The Journal of Economic Perspectives XX, 73–96. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- 2008] Corporate governance and firm performance, Journal of Corporate Finance XIV, 257–273. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- M. P. Blum (1969) The Failing Company Doctrine. Doctoral Dissertation, UMI Dissertation Services. Google Scholar
- 2011] Financial and economic determinants of firm default, Journal of Evolutionary Economics XXI, 373–406. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- 2007] Should the CEO also be chair of the board? An empirical examination of family-controlled public firms, Family Business Review XX, 111–126. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- 2011] Corporate governance and family business performance, Journal of Business Research LXIV, 280–285. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- 2010] Corporate governance myths: Comments on Armstrong, Guay, and Weber, Journal of Accounting and Economics L, 235–245. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- 2001] Family as source, user, and builder of social capital, The Journal of Socioeconomics XXX, 129–131. Google Scholar [
- 2017] Governance structure and internationalization of family-controlled firms: the mediating role of international entrepreneurial orientation, European Management Journal XXXV, 238–248. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- 2020] Keys to the survival of the family firm: long-lived family firms, Competitiveness, Organizational Management, and Governance in Family Firms X, 234–259. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- 2020] Cash holdings in family firms: CEO identity and implications for firm value, European Financial Management XXVI, 386–415. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- 2005] Corporate governance and competitive advantage in family-controlled firms, Entrepreneurship Theory and Practice XXVIV, 249–265. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- CERVED (2018) Rapporto Cerved PMI 2018 [online] Available at: https://know.cerved.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/11/PMI-2018-intero.pdf. Google Scholar
- 2014] Transparency and financing choices of family firms, Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis XLIX, 381–408. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- 2018] Too much of a good thing: Family involvement and the survival of listed Korean firms, Journal of Family Business Strategy IX, 223–237. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- 2012] Variations in R&D investments of family and nonfamily firms: behavioral agency and myopic loss aversion perspectives, Academy of Management Journal LV, 976–997. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- 2003] Creating wealth in family firms through managing resources: Comments and extensions, Entrepreneurship Theory and Practice XXVII, 359–365. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- 2018] Investigation of financial distress with a dynamic logit based on the linkage between liquidity and profitability status of listed firms, Journal of the Operational Research Society [online] Available at https://doi.org/10.1080/01605682.2018.1460017 Google Scholar [
- 2011] Family ownership and firm performance: Influence of family management, family control, and firm size, Asia Pacific Journal of Management XXVIII, 833–851. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- 2011] Family involvement and new venture debt financing, Journal of Business Venturing XXVI, 472–488. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- 2012] Sources of heterogeneity in family firms: an introduction, Entrepreneurship Theory and Practice XXXVI, 1103–1113. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- 2008] Using economic-financial ratios for small enterprise default prediction modeling: An empirical analysis, In 2008 Oxford Business and Economics Conference Proceedings, Association for Business and Economics Research (ABER), pp. 1–21. Google Scholar [
- 2015] Corporate governance characteristics and default prediction modeling for small enterprises. an empirical analysis of Italian firms, Journal of Business Research LXVIII, 1012–1025. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- 2015] Do family firms have better access to external finance during crises?, Corporate Governance: An International Review XXIII, 249–265. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- 2011] Family control and financing decisions, European Financial Management XVII, 860–897. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- 2000] A comparative analysis of current credit risk models, Journal of Banking and Finance XXIV, 59–117. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- 2013] Determinants of SME credit worthiness under Basel rules: The value of credit history information, PSL Quarterly Review LXVI, 21–47. Google Scholar [
- 2013] Dispersion of family ownership and the performance of small-to-medium size private family firms, Journal of Family Business Strategy IV, 166–175. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- 2015] The impact of family involvement on SMEs’ performance: theory and evidence, Journal of Small Business Management LIII, 924–948. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- 2007] Corporate governance and the value of cash holdings, Journal of Financial Economics LXXXIII, 599–634. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- 1961] Corporate Debt Capacity. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press. Google Scholar [
- 2011] Boards, CEOs, and surviving a financial crisis: Evidence from the internet shakeout, Strategic Management Journal XXXII, 1025–1045. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- 2005] Determinants of board participation in the strategic decisions of small corporations, Entrepreneurship Theory and Practice XXVIV, 627–650. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- 2000] CEO stakes and board composition in small private firms, Entrepreneurship Theory and Practice, XXIV, 5–24. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- 2005] Corporate governance and performance in publicly listed, family-controlled firms: evidence from Taiwan, Asia Pacific Journal of Management XXII, 257–283. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- P. Foulquier & F. Herbin (2015) Pourquoi les entreprises familiales recourent-elles moins àla dette que les entreprises non familiales?, Working Paper, Edhec Business School. Google Scholar
- 2003] Testing the pecking order theory of capital structure, Journal of Financial Economics LXVII, 217–248. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- 2016] Family businesses and performance: A meta-analysis of empirical studies, Sinergie XXXIV, 377–395. Google Scholar [
- 2017] Finance in family business: A systematic literature review, International Journal of Business Administration VIII, 11–27. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- 2011] Board characteristics and firm performance in public founder- and nonfounder-led family businesses, Journal of Family Business Strategy II, 220–231. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- 1990] Bankruptcy, boards, banks, and blockholders: Evidence on changes in corporate ownership and control when firms default, Journal of Financial Economics XXVII, 355–387. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- 2018] Corporate governance and firm survival, Financial Review LIII, 209–253. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- 2003] The determinants of executive compensation in family-controlled public corporations, Academy of Management Journal XLVI, 226–237. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- 2013] Family firms and debt: Risk aversion versus risk of losing control, Journal of Business Research LXVI, 2308–2320. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- 1994] The effects of board size and diversity on strategic change, Strategic Management Journal XV, 241–250. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- 2010] Multivariate Data Analysis. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice Hall. Google Scholar [
- 2008] Corporate governance and firm cash holdings in the US, Journal of Financial Economics LXXXVII, 535–555. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- 2002] Optimal capital structure and endogenous default, Finance and Stochastics, VI, 237–263. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- 2018] Capital structure and firms’ determinants: evidence from surviving family and non-family listed companies in Malaysia, In Proceedings of Asia Conference on Business and Economic Studies (ACBES),
University of Economics Ho Chi Minh City ,8–9 September 2018 , Ho Chi Minh City, Vietnam, UEH Publishing House, pp. 676–703. Google Scholar [ - 1976] Theory of the firm: managerial behavior, agency costs and ownership structure, Journal of Financial Economics III, 305–360. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- 1986] Agency costs of free cash flow, corporate finance, and takeovers, The American Economic Review LXXVI, 323–329. Google Scholar [
- 2019] The effect of corporate governance and family ownership on firm value, Review of Integrative Business and Economics Research VIII, 168–178. Google Scholar [
- 1980] Financial Ratios as Predictors of Borrowers’ Health: With Reference to Small-scale Industries in India. New Delhi: Sultan [pref. 1980]. Google Scholar [
- 2004] Les entreprises familiales. Paris: Presse Universitaire de France. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- 2003] On the strategic accumulation of intangible assets, Organization Science XIV, 192–207. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- 1973] A state-preference model of optimal financial leverage, The Journal of Finance XXVIII, 911–922. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- 2020] The moderating role of Shariah-Complian[ce] in the relationship between free cash flow and profitability in [a] family firm, In 3rd Asia Pacific International Conference of Management and Business Science (AICMBS 2019) Atlantis Press, pp. 9–12. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- 2007] Financial structure of the family business: Evidence from a group of small Spanish firms, Family Business Review XX, 269–287. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- 2006] Guidelines for family business boards of directors, Family Business Review XIX, 147–167. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- 2007] Corporate governance, accounting outcomes and organizational performance, The Accounting Review LXXXII, 963–1008. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- 2017] Outside CEOs, board control and the financing policy of small privately held family firms, Journal of Family Business Strategy VIII, 29–41. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- 2015] Governance and entrepreneurship in family firms: agency, behavioral agency and resource-based comparisons, Journal of Family Business Strategy VI, 58–62. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- 2017] The relationship between entrepreneurial orientation and firm performance: Influence of family governance, Journal of Family Business Strategy VIII, 213–223. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- 2014] Internal governance mechanism and default probability: Evidence from US public firms, International Journal of Corporate Governance V, 83–102. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- 2016] Financial ratios and corporate governance indicators in bankruptcy prediction: A comprehensive study, European Journal of Operational Research XXV, 561–572. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- 2007] An organizational justice-based view of self-control and agency costs in family firms, Journal of Management Studies XLIV, 955–971. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- 2007] An embeddedness framing of governance and opportunism: Towards a cross-nationally accommodating theory of agency, Journal of Organizational Behavior: The International Journal of Industrial, Occupational and Organizational Psychology and Behavior XXVIII, 43–58. Google Scholar [
- 2019] Firm failure processes and components of failure risk: An analysis of European bankrupt firms, Journal of Business Research IIC, 380–390. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- 2011] Long-term orientation and intertemporal choice in family firms, Entrepreneurship Theory and Practice XXXV, 1149–1169. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- 2019] The effect of corporate governance on profitability, capital structure and corporate value, Research Journal of Finance and Accounting X, 202–214. Google Scholar [
- 2011] Family business and financial performance: current state of knowledge and future research challenges, Journal of Family Business Strategy II, 166–181. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- 2000] Family CEOs vs. nonfamily CEOs in the family-controlled firm: An examination of the level and sensitivity of pay to performance, Family Business Review, XIII, 121–131. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- 2015] Voluntary corporate governance structure and financial distress: Evidence from Australia, Journal of Contemporary Accounting and Economics XI, 18–30. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- 2018] Capital structure determinants in family firms: An empirical analysis in context of crisis, International Business Research XI, 65–80. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- 2003] Challenge versus advantage in family business, Strategic Organization I, 127–134. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- 2005] Managing for the Long Run: Lessons in Competitive Advantage from Great Family Businesses. US: Harvard Business Press. Google Scholar [
- 2006] Family governance and firm performance: agency, stewardship, and capabilities, Family Business Review XIX, 73–87. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- 2014] Deconstructing socioemotional wealth, Entrepreneurship Theory and Practice XXXVIII, 713–720. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- 2008] Stewardship vs. stagnation: an empirical comparison of small family and non-family businesses, Journal of Management Studies XLV, 51–78. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- 2016] Weathering the storm: Family ownership, governance, and performance through the financial and economic crisis, Corporate Governance: An International Review XXIV, 552–568. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- 2014] A default prediction model for Italian SMEs: The relevance of the capital structure, Applied Financial Economics XXIV, 1537–1554. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- 2010] Family business succession and its impact on financial structure and performance, Family Business Review XXIII, pp. 131–147. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- P. Murro & V. Peruzzi (2017) Family Firms and Access to Credit. Is Family Ownership Beneficial? CERBE Center for Relationship Banking and Economics. NBER Working Paper n. C23. Google Scholar
- 1984] Corporate financing and investment decisions when firms have information that investors do not have, Journal of Financial Economics XIII, 187–221. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- 1984] The capital structure puzzle, Journal of Finance IXL, 219–230. Google Scholar [
- 1998] Social capital, intellectual capital, and the organizational advantage, Academy of Management Review XXIII, 242–266. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- 2010] Top management team diversity: A review of theories and methodologies, International Journal of Management Reviews XII, 301–316. Crossref, Google Scholar [
-
J. M. Pollack & M. W. Rutherford [2012] Exploring the relation between family involvement and firms’ financial performance: A meta-analysis of main and moderator effects, Journal of Business Venturing XXVII, 1–18. Crossref, Google Scholar , - 1980] Financial ratios and the probabilistic prediction of bankruptcy, Journal of Accounting Research, XVIII, 109–131. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- 2018] Pecking order and trade-off theory in capital structure analysis of family firms in Indonesia, Jurnal Keuangan dan Perbankan XXII, 73–82. Google Scholar [
- 2006] Inherited control and firm performance, American Economic Review, XCVI, 1559–1588. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- 2007] Mechanisms to Assure Long-Term Family Business Survival: A Study of the Dynamics of Cohesion in Multigenerational Family Business Families. Frankfurt: Peter Lang. Google Scholar [
- 2019] Accounting for family and business overlaps, Journal of Management History X, 15–30. Google Scholar [
- 2018] The impact of family ownership on capital structure of firms: Exploring the role of zero-leverage, size, location and the global financial crisis, International Small Business Journal XXXVI, 574–604. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- 1993] Regression standard errors in clustered samples, Stata Technical Bulletin III, 19–23. Google Scholar [
- 2019] Family ownership concentration and firm internationalization: integrating principal-principal and socioemotional wealth perspectives, Journal of International Entrepreneurship XVII, 220–248. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- 2001] Agency relationships in family firms: Theory and evidence, Organization Science XII, 99–116. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- 2003a] Exploring the agency consequences of ownership dispersion among the directors of private family firms, Academy of Management Journal XLVI, 179–194. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- 2003b] Toward a theory of agency and altruism in family firms, Journal of Business Venturing XVIII, 473–490. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- 2008] Family involvement in ownership and management: Exploring nonlinear effects on performance, Family Business Review XXI, 331–345. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- 1986] Large shareholders and corporate control, Journal of Political Economy XCIV, 461–488. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- 1999] Board structure, ownership, and financial distress in banking firms, International Review of Economics and Finance VIII, 281–292. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- 2001] Predicting corporate failure in Malaysia: an application of the Logit Model to financial ratio analysis, Asian Academy of Management Journal VI, 99–118. Google Scholar [
- The European House Ambrosetti (2018) [online] Available at https://www.ambrosetti.eu/en/managementconsulting/family-businesses-and-governance/family-business/. Google Scholar
- 2006] How do family ownership, control and management affect firm value?, Journal of Financial Economics LXXX, 385–417. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- 2007] Board composition in small and medium-sized family firms, Journal of Small Business Management XLV, 137–156. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- 2006] Corporate governance and financial distress: Evidence from Chinese listed companies, Chinese Economy XXXIX, 5–27. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- 2013] Family business survival and the role of boards, Entrepreneurship Theory and Practice XXXVII, 1369–1389. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- 2002] Econometric Analysis of Cross-section and Panel Data. Cambridge, MA: The MIT Press. Google Scholar [
- 2007] Effects of family ownership and management on small business equity financing, Journal of Business Venturing XXII, 875–895. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- 2008] On the emotional value of owning a firm, Family Business Review XXI, 347–363. Crossref, Google Scholar [
- 1995] Évaluation du risque de défaillance de l’entreprise: méthodes et cas d’application. Paris: Economica. Google Scholar [