Special Issue on "Climate Change Policy"No Access

COOPERATION TO REDUCE DEVELOPING COUNTRY EMISSIONS

SUZI KERR

Motu Economic and Public Policy Research, Level 1, 97 Cuba St, PO Box 24390, Wellington 6142, New Zealand

Search for more papers by this author

and

ADAM MILLARD-BALL

Environmental Studies Department, University of California, Santa Cruz, 1156, High St, Santa Cruz, CA 95064, USA

Search for more papers by this author

https://doi.org/10.1142/S2010007812500236Cited by:5 (Source: Crossref)

Abstract

Without effective developing country (DC) participation in climate mitigation, it will be impossible to meet global concentration and climate change targets. However, DCS are unwilling and, in many cases, unable to bear the mitigation cost alone. They need huge transfers of resources — financial, knowledge, technology and capability — from industrialized countries (ICs). In this paper, we evaluate instruments that can induce such resource transfers, including tradable credits, mitigation funds and results-based agreements. We identify key constraints that affect the efficiency and political potential of different instruments, including two-sided private information leading to adverse selection; moral hazard and challenging negotiations; incomplete contracts leading to under-investment; and high levels of uncertainty about emissions paths and mitigation potential. We consider evidence on the poor performance of current approaches to funding DC mitigation — primarily purchasing offsets through the Clean Development Mechanism — and explore to what extent other approaches can address problems with offsets. We emphasize the wide spectrum of situations in DCS and suggest that solutions also need to be differentiated and that no one policy will suffice: some policies will be complements, while others are substitutes. We conclude by identifying research needs and proposing a straw man to broaden the range of "contracting" options considered.

Keywords:

References

P. Aghion, M. Dewatripont and P. Rey, European Economic Review 34(3), 322 (1990). Crossref, Google Scholar
J. E. Aldy and R. N. Stavins (eds.) , Architectures for Agreement: Addressing Global Climate Change in the Post-Kyoto World ( Cambridge University Press , Cambridge , 2007 ) . Crossref, Google Scholar
Angelsen, A and TK Rudel (2012). Implementing REDD+ amidst a forest transition: The policy challenges. Unpublished paper . Google Scholar
N. Anger, C. Böringer and U. Moslener, Climate Policy 7(6), 500 (2007). Crossref, Google Scholar
S. Bakkeret al., Climate Policy 11(1), 752 (2011). Crossref, Google Scholar
S. Barrett, Oxford Economic Papers 46(1), 878 (1994). Crossref, Google Scholar
P. Bolton, European Economic Review 34(3), 303 (1990). Crossref, Google Scholar
Bosi, M and J Ellis (2005). Exploring options for sectoral crediting mechanisms. OECD and International Energy Agency, Paris . Google Scholar
Boyd, E, NE Hultman, T Roberts, E Corbera, J Ebeling, DM Liverman, K Brown, R Tippmann, J Cole, P Mann et al. (2007). The Clean Development Mechanism: An assessment of current practice and future approaches for policy. Tyndall Centre Working Paper 114, Tyndall Centre for Climate Change Research UK, Norwich . Google Scholar
J. Buschet al., Environmental Research Letters 4(4), 44006 (2009). Crossref, Google Scholar
Busch, J, R Lubowski, F Godoy, M Steininger, AA. Yusuf, K Austin, J Hewson, D Juhn, M Farid and F Boltz (2011). Structuring national and sub-national economic incentives to reduce emissions from deforestation in Indonesia. Working Paper in Economics and Development Studies 201105, Department of Economics, Padjadjaran University, Indonesia . Google Scholar
Bushnell, J (2011). Adverse selection and emissions offsets. Iowa State University Working Paper No. 11004, Department of Economics, Ames . Google Scholar
Center for Clean Air Policy (2009). Nationally appropriate mitigation actions by developing countries: Architecture and key issues, Center for Clean Air Policy, Washington, DC . Google Scholar
K. M. Chomitz, Climate Policy 2(1), 35 (2002). Crossref, Google Scholar
Datta, A and E Somanathan (2011). Climate policy and innovation in the absence of commitment. Discussion Paper 2011-45, Harvard Project on Climate Agreements, Cambridge, MA . Google Scholar
H. De Coninck, F. Haake and N. van der Linden, Climate Policy 7(5), 444 (2007). Crossref, Google Scholar
T. Dyck, Columbia Journal of Environmental Law 36(2), 259 (2011). Google Scholar
J. Elliset al., Energy Policy 35(1), 15 (2007). Crossref, Google Scholar
Fell, H, D Burtraw, R Morgenstern and K Palmer (2010). Climate policy design with correlated uncertainties in offset supply and abatement cost. RFF Discussion Paper 10-01, Resources for the Future, Washington, DC . Google Scholar
Fischer, C and AK Fox (2011). The role of trade and competitiveness measures in U.S. climate policy. Prepared for American Economic Review Papers and Proceedings 2011 . Google Scholar
C. Flachsland, R. Marschinski and O. Edenhofer, Climate Policy 9(4), 358 (2009). Crossref, Google Scholar
F. Flues, A. Michaelowa and K. Michaelowa, Public Choice 145(2), 1 (2010). Crossref, Google Scholar
C. Gavardet al., Climate Change Economics 2(1), 9 (2011). Link, Google Scholar
M. Grubbet al., Climatic Change 104(4), 539 (2011). Crossref, Google Scholar
Hahn, R and KR Richards (2010). Environmental offset programs: Survey and synthesis, Indiana University School of Public & Environmental Affairs Research Paper No. 2010-12-01 . Google Scholar
D. S. Hallet al., Post-Kyoto International Climate Policy Implementing Architectures for Agreement, eds. J. E. Aldy and R. N. Stavins (Cambridge University Press, 2010) pp. 649–681. Google Scholar
Harstad, B (2009). The dynamics of climate agreements. Harvard Project on Climate Agreements. Discussion Paper 09–28 Cambridge, MA . Google Scholar
Haya, B (2009). Measuring emissions against an alternative future: Fundamental flaws in the structure of the Kyoto Protocol's Clean Development Mechanism. Energy and Resources Group Working Paper ERG09-001, University of California, Berkeley . Google Scholar
He, G and RK Morse (2010). Making carbon offsets work in the developing world: Lessons from the Chinese wind controversy. PESD Working Paper #90, Stanford University Program on Energy and Sustainable Development, Stanford, CA . Google Scholar
Heindl, P and S Voigt (2011). A practical approach to offset permits in post Kyoto climate policy. Discussion Paper No. 11-043, Centre for European Economic Research, Mannheim, Germany . Google Scholar
Hellerstein, D, N Higgins and MJ Roberts (2011). Using quotas to enhance competition in asymmetric auctions: A comparison of theoretical and experimental outcomes. Working Paper. Available at http://www4.ncsu.edu/∼mjrober2/main/Working_Papers_files/quota03_18_2011.pdf . Google Scholar
C. Hepburn, Annual Review of Environment & Resources 32(1), 375 (2007). Crossref, Google Scholar
S. P. Holland, J. E. Hughes and C. R. Knittel, American Economic Journal: Economic Policy 1(1), 106 (2009). Crossref, Google Scholar
A. Karsenty and S. Ongolo , Forest Policy and Economics 18 , 38 ( 2012 ) . Crossref, Google Scholar
R. O. Keohane, Institutions for Environmental Aid, eds. R. O. Keohane and M. A. Levy (MIT Press, Cambridge, MA, 1996) pp. 3–27. Google Scholar
R. O. Keohane and K. Raustiala , Post-Kyoto International Climate Policy: Implementing Architectures for Agreement , eds. R. N. Stavins and J. E. Aldy ( Cambridge University Press , New York , 2009 ) . Google Scholar
Kerr, S (1995a). Adverse selection and participation in international environmental agreements. In Contracts and Tradeable Permit Markets in International and Domestic Environmental Protection, Ph.D. thesis, Harvard University . Google Scholar
Kerr, S (1995b). Alternative institutions for implementation of international environmental agreements: Ozone depletion and the Montreal Protocol. In Contracts and Tradeable Permit Markets in International and Domestic Environmental Protection, Ph.D. thesis, Harvard University . Google Scholar
Kerr, S (2011). The economics of international policies to reduce emissions from deforestation and degradation. Unpublished paper . Google Scholar
F. Lecocq and P. Ambrosi, Review of Environmental Economics and Policy 1(1), 134 (2007). Crossref, Google Scholar
X. M. Liu, Energy Policy 36(6), 1873 (2008). Crossref, Google Scholar
Mason, C and A Platinga (2011). Contracting for impure public goods: Carbon offsets and additionality. NBER Working Paper No. 16963, National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA . Google Scholar
P. Meyfroidt, T. K. Rudel and E. F. Lambin, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 107(49), 20917 (2010). Crossref, Google Scholar
A. Michaelowa and K. Michaelowa, Climatic Change 84(1), 5 (2007). Crossref, Google Scholar
Millaral-Ball, A (2012). The trouble with voluntary emissions trading: Uncertainty and adverse selection in sectoral crediting programs. Journal of Environmental Economics and Management, Online First, http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jeem.2012.05.007 . Google Scholar
A. Millard-Ball and L. Ortolano, Energy Policy 38(1), 533 (2010). Crossref, Google Scholar
J.-P. Montero, Journal of Political Economy 107(5), 998 (1999). Crossref, Google Scholar
J.-P. Montero, Journal of Public Economics 75(2), 273 (2000). Crossref, Google Scholar
J.-P. Montero, American Economic Review 98(1), 496 (2008). Crossref, Google Scholar
A. Muller, Energy Policy 35(6), 3203 (2007). Crossref, Google Scholar
R. B. Myerson and M. A. Satterthwaite, Journal of Economic Theory 29(2), 265 (1983). Crossref, Google Scholar
U. Narain and K. Veld, Environmental and Resource Economics 40(3), 445 (2008). Crossref, Google Scholar
D. Nepstadet al., Science 326(5958), 1350 (2009). Crossref, Google Scholar
K. H. Olsen, Climatic Change 84(1), 59 (2007). Crossref, Google Scholar
E. Ostrom , Governing the commons: The Evolution of Institutions for Collective Action ( Cambridge University Press , Cambridge , 1990 ) . Crossref, Google Scholar
E. Paulsson, International Environmental Agreements: Politics, Law & Economics 9(1), 63 (2009). Crossref, Google Scholar
D. Popp, Review of Environmental Economics and Policy 5(1), 131 (2011). Crossref, Google Scholar
Reilly, J, M Sarofim, S Paltsev and RG Prinn (2006). The role of non-CO2 greenhouse gases in climate policy: Analysis using the MIT IGSM. Energy Journal: Multi-Greenhouse Gas Mitigation and Climate Policy Special Issue, #3, 503–520 . Google Scholar
D. Rodrik, Journal of Development Economics 36(2), 229 (1991). Crossref, Google Scholar
Rosendahl, KE and J Strand (2009). Carbon leakage from the Clean Development Mechanism. Discussion Papers No. 591, Statistics Norway Research Department, Oslo . Google Scholar
A. Sanchez-Azofeifaet al., Conservation Biology 21(5), 1165 (2007). Crossref, Google Scholar
J. Schmidtet al., Climate Policy 8(5), 494 (2006). Crossref, Google Scholar
Schneider, L (2007). Is the CDM fulfilling its environmental and sustainable development objectives? An evaluation of the CDM and options for improvement. Report prepared for WWF, Öko-Institut e.V., Berlin . Google Scholar
L. Schneider, Climate Policy 9(3), 242 (2009). Crossref, Google Scholar
Schneider, L and M Cames (2009). A framework for a sectoral crediting mechanism in a post-2012 climate regime. Report for the Global Wind Energy Council, Öko-Institut e.V., Berlin . Google Scholar
P. Seabright, Journal of Economic Perspectives 7(4), 113 (1993). Crossref, Google Scholar
P. Seabright, The Environment and Emerging Development Issues 2, eds. P. Dasgupta and K.-G. Mäler (Clarendon Press, Oxford, 1997) pp. 283–307. Google Scholar
J. Strand, Energy Economics 33(2), 371 (2011). Crossref, Google Scholar
C. Sutter and J. C. Parreño, Climatic Change 84(1), 75 (2007). Crossref, Google Scholar
M. C. Trexler, D. J. Broekhoff and L. H. Kosloff, Sustainable Development Law & Policy 6(2), 30 (2006). Google Scholar
UNFCCC (2008). Tool for the demonstration and assessment of additionality. Version 5.2. UNFCCC, Bonn . Google Scholar
van Benthem, A and S Kerr (2010). Optimizing voluntary deforestation policy in the face of adverse selection and costly transfers. Motu Working Paper 10-04, Motu Economic and Public Policy Research, Wellington, NZ . Google Scholar
van Benthem, A and S Kerr (2011). Bigger is better: Avoided deforestation offsets in the face of adverse selection. PESD Working Paper #102, Stanford University Program on Energy and Sustainable Development, Stanford, CA . Google Scholar
A. Vasa, Climate Policy 12(6), 645 (2012). Crossref, Google Scholar
D. G. Victor , Global Warming Gridlock ( Cambridge University Press , Cambridge , 2011 ) . Crossref, Google Scholar
F. Vöhringer, T. Kuosmanen and R. B. Dellink, Climate Policy 5(5), 503 (2006). Crossref, Google Scholar
Wang-Helmreich, H, W Sterk, T Wehnert and C Arens (2011). Current developments in pilot nationally appropriate mitigation actions of developing countries (NAMAs). JIKO Policy Paper 01/2011, Wuppertal Institute, Wuppertal . Google Scholar
M. Wara , UCLA Law Review 55 , 1759 ( 2008 ) . Google Scholar
Wara, M and D Victor (2008). A realistic policy on international carbon offsets. PESD Working Paper #74, Stanford University Program on Energy and Sustainable Development, Stanford, CA . Google Scholar

Remember to check out the Most Cited Articles!
Be inspired by these New titles in Energy, Resource & Environmental Economics today. Featuring authors from Princeton, Columbia University, Imperial College Business School and many more!