No Access

EVALUATING WOMEN ENTREPRENEURS IN THE INFORMAL SECTOR: SOME EVIDENCE FROM INDIA

COLIN C WILLIAMS

University of Sheffield, South Yorkshire S10 2TN, United Kingdom

Search for more papers by this author

and

ANJULA GURTOO

Indian Institute of Science, Bangalore 560 012, India

Search for more papers by this author

https://doi.org/10.1142/S1084946711001914Cited by:37 (Source: Crossref)

Abstract

Studies on women entrepreneurs in the informal economy no longer view them merely as a residue from some pre-modern mode of production that is disappearing. Instead, they are either read through a structuralist lens as marginalized populations engaged in low quality work conducted under poor conditions for low pay out of necessity in the absence of alternative means of livelihood, or through a neo-liberal lens as engaged in relatively higher quality endeavours more as a rational choice. The aim of this paper is to evaluate critically these contrasting explanations. To do this, the results of face-to-face interviews with 323 women entrepreneurs operating in the Indian informal economy are analyzed. The finding is that although the structuralist representation is largely appropriate for women engaged in informal waged work, it is not as valid for women informal entrepreneurs working on a self-employed basis where incomes are higher, they receive more credit from informal institutions, union membership is higher, and such work is more likely to be a rational choice. The outcome is a call to recognize the diversity of women's experiences in the informal sector and that not all informal entrepreneurship by women in developing nations is a low-paid, necessity-oriented endeavour carried out as a last resort.

The authors would like to acknowledge Paycheck India and Wage Indicator Foundation, The Netherlands for funding the survey reported in this paper. The usual disclaimers apply.

Keywords:

References

H. E. Aldrich , Organizations Evolving ( Sage , Thousand Oaks, CA , 1999 ) . Google Scholar
H. E. Aldrich, P. R. Reese and P. Dubini, Entrepreneurship and Regional Development 1(4), 339 (1989), DOI: 10.1080/08985628900000029. Crossref, Google Scholar
A. Amin , A. Cameron and R. Hudson , Placing the Social Economy ( Routledge , London , 2002 ) . Crossref, Google Scholar
A. R. Anderson and M. Starnawska, International Journal of Entrepreneurship and Innovation 9(4), 221 (2008), DOI: 10.5367/000000008786208731. Crossref, Google Scholar
E. Bhatt , We are Poor but so Many: The Story of Self-employed Women in India ( Oxford University Press , New Delhi , 2006 ) . Google Scholar
J. J. Biles, Professional Geographer 60(4), 541 (2008), DOI: 10.1080/00330120802288743. Crossref, Google Scholar
J. J. Biles, Geography Compass 3(1), 214 (2009), DOI: 10.1111/j.1749-8198.2008.00188.x. Crossref, Google Scholar
K. E. Browne , Creole Economics: Caribbean Cunning Under the French Flag ( University of Texas , Austin , 2004 ) . Crossref, Google Scholar
Carr, M and M Chen (2004). Globalization, Social Exclusion and Work With Special Reference to Informal Employment and Gender. Policy Integration Department Working Paper No. 20, Geneva: International Labor Office . Google Scholar
Carr, M and M Chen (2002). Globalization and the Informal Economy: How Global Trade and Investment Impact on the Working Poor. Working Paper on the Informal Economy Working No. 1 INTEGRATION, Geneva: International Labor Office . Google Scholar
M. Castells and A. Portes , The Informal Economy: Studies in Advanced and Less Developing Countries , eds. A. Portes , M. Castells and L. A. Benton ( John Hopkins University Press , Baltimore , 1989 ) . Google Scholar
Chan, A (2003). A 'race of the bottom': Globalisation and China's labour standards. China Perspectives, 46(March–April), 41–49 . Google Scholar
S. Chant , The Companion to Development Studies , 2nd edn. , eds. V. Desai and R. Potter ( Hodder-Arnold , London , 2007 ) . Google Scholar
Chant, S (2007b). Addressing Gender Inequalities in Cities of the South: What Role for the Millennium Development Goals?, Paper prepared for UNU–WIDER Project Workshop: Beyond the Tipping Point: Development in an Urban World, London School of Economics, October . Google Scholar
J. Charmes , Is Informal Normal? Towards More and Better Jobs in Developing Countries , eds. J. P. Jütting and J. R. Laiglesia ( OECD , Paris , 2009 ) . Google Scholar
M. J. Chen , M. Carr and J. Vanek , Mainstreaming Informal Employment and Gender in Poverty Reduction: A Handbook for Policymakers and Other Stakeholders ( Commonwealth Secretariat , London , 2004 ) . Google Scholar
M. J. Chen, R. Sebstad and L. Connell, World Development 27(3), 603 (1999), DOI: 10.1016/S0305-750X(98)00154-5. Crossref, Google Scholar
S. E. S. Crawford and E. Ostrom, American Political Science Review 89(3), 582 (1995). Crossref, Google Scholar
J. Cross and A. Morales , Street Entrepreneurs: People, Place and Politics in Local and Global Perspective ( Routledge , London , 2007 ) . Crossref, Google Scholar
K. Das , Informal Economy Center Stage: New Structures of Employment , eds. R. Jhabvala , R. M. Sudarshan and J. Unni ( Sage , London , 2003 ) . Google Scholar
H. De Soto , The Other Path: The Economic Answer to Terrorism ( Harper and Row , London , 1989 ) . Google Scholar
H. De Soto , The Mystery of Capital: Why Capitalism Triumphs in the West and Fails Everywhere Else ( Black Swan , London , 2001 ) . Google Scholar
D. Doane , D. Srikajon and R. Ofreneo , Chains of Production, Ladders of Protection: Social Protection for Workers in the Informal Economy , eds. F. Lund and J. Nicholson ( School of Development Studies, University of Natal , Durban , 2003 ) . Google Scholar
European Commission (2007). Stepping up the Fight Against Undeclared Work. Brussels: European Commission . Google Scholar
M. Evans , S. Syrett and C. C. Williams , The Informal Economy and Deprived Neighborhoods: A Systematic Review ( Department of Communities and Local Government , London , 2006 ) . Google Scholar
Fawzi, C (2003). Gender, Poverty and Employment in the Arab Region. Capacity-Building Program on Gender, Poverty and Employment, Discussion Paper. Geneva: International Labor Office . Google Scholar
E. L. Feige and I. Urban, Journal of Comparative Economics 36, 287 (2008), DOI: 10.1016/j.jce.2008.02.003. Crossref, Google Scholar
D. Gallin, Antipode 19(4), 531 (2001). Google Scholar
L. C. Gates, Bulletin of Latin American Research 21(4), 507 (2002), DOI: 10.1111/1470-9856.00057. Crossref, Google Scholar
C. Geertz , Peddlers and Princes: Social Development and Economic Change in Two Indonesian Towns ( University of Chicago Press , Chicago , 1963 ) . Google Scholar
Government of India (2001). Report of the Task Force on Employment Opportunities. Planning Commission, July, GOI . Google Scholar
A. Gurtoo, The International Journal of Knowledge, Culture and Change Management 8(7), 11 (2008). Crossref, Google Scholar
A. Gurtoo , Perspectives in Knowledge Management , eds. I. V. Malhan and S. Rao ( Scarecrow Press , USA , 2008 ) . Google Scholar
Harding, R, D Brooksbank, M Hart, D Jones-Evans, J Levie, J O'Reilly and J Walker (2006). Global Entrepreneurship Monitor United Kingdom 2005. London Business School, London: Global Entrepreneurship Monitor . Google Scholar
R. Hudson , Economic Geographies: Circuits, Flows and Spaces ( Sage , London , 2005 ) . Crossref, Google Scholar
International Labor Office (ILO) (2002a). Decent Work and the Informal Economy. Geneva: International Labor Office . Google Scholar
International Labor Office (ILO) (2002b). Women and Men in the Informal Economy: A Statistical Picture. Geneva: International Labor Office . Google Scholar
International Labor Office (ILO) , Gender Equality and Decent Work: Selected ILO Conventions and Recommendations Promoting Gender Equality ( International Labor Office , Geneva , 2006 ) . Google Scholar
International Labor Office (ILO) , Decent Work for Women and Men in the Informal Economy: Profile and Good Practices in Cambodia ( International Labor Office , Geneva , 2006 ) . Google Scholar
J. Itzigsohn , Developing Poverty: The State, Labor Market Deregulation and the Informal Economy in Costa Rica and the Dominican Republic ( Pennsylvania State University Press , PA , 2000 ) . Google Scholar
J. P. Jütting and J. R. Laiglesia , Is Informal Normal? Towards More and Better Jobs in Developing Countries , eds. J. P. Jütting and J. R. Laiglesia ( OECD , Paris , 2009 ) . Crossref, Google Scholar
A. Kapoor, Futures 39, 554 (2007), DOI: 10.1016/j.futures.2006.10.004. Crossref, Google Scholar
L. L. Kiser and E. Ostrom, Strategies of Political Enquiry, ed. E. Ostrom (Sage Publications, Beverly Hills, California, 1982) pp. 179–222. Google Scholar
A. Kohli , The State and Poverty in India: The Politics of Reform ( Cambridge University Press , Cambridge , 1987 ) . Crossref, Google Scholar
A. Lewis , The Theory of Economic Growth ( Allen and Unwin , London , 1959 ) . Google Scholar
Lund, F and S Srinivas (2000). Learning From Experience: A Gendered Approach to Social Protection for Workers in the Informal Economy, Strategies and Tools Against Social Exclusion and Poverty (STEP) and Women in Informal Employment: Globalizing and Organizing. WIEGO, Geneva: International Labor Office . Google Scholar
P. D. Little , Somalia: Economy Without State ( Indiana University Press , Bloomington , 2003 ) . Google Scholar
W. F. Maloney, World Development 32(7), 1159 (2004), DOI: 10.1016/j.worlddev.2004.01.008. Crossref, Google Scholar
Mehrotra, S and M Biggeri (2002). Social Protection in the Informal Economy: Home Based Women Workers and Outsourced Manufacturing in Asia. Innocenti working paper no. 97. Florence: UNICEF Innocenti Research Unit . Google Scholar
S. C. L. Minard, Social Enterprise Journal 5(3), 186 (2009), DOI: 10.1108/17508610911004304. Crossref, Google Scholar
A. Minc, Le Debat 2, 3 (1980), DOI: 10.3917/deba.002.0003. Crossref, Google Scholar
National Knowledge Commission (2009). Report to the nation 2006–2009. NKC report, Government of India Press, New Delhi . Google Scholar
National Sample Survey Organization (2005). National Sample Survey 2005. New Delhi: The Ministry of Statistics and Program Implementation, Coordination and Publication Division . Google Scholar
E. Nelson and E. Bruijn, Journal of International Development 17, 575 (2005), DOI: 10.1002/jid.1176. Crossref, Google Scholar
N. Nelson , Cities in the Developing World: Issues, Theory, Policy , ed. J. Gugler ( Oxford University Press , Oxford , 1997 ) . Google Scholar
OECD , Measuring the Non-Observed Economy ( OECD , Paris , 2002 ) . Crossref, Google Scholar
E. Ostrom , Governing the Commons: The Evolution of Institutions for Collective Action ( Cambridge University Press , Cambridge , 1990 ) . Crossref, Google Scholar
E. Ostrom, Annual Review of Political Science 2, 493 (1999), DOI: 10.1146/annurev.polisci.2.1.493. Crossref, Google Scholar
M. Otero , Contrapunto: The Informal Sector Debate in Latin America , ed. C. A. Rakowski ( State University of New York Press , Albany , 1994 ) . Google Scholar
Packard, T (2007). Do Workers in Chile Choose Informal Employment? A Dynamic Analysis of Sector Choice, Washington DC: World Bank, Latin America and Caribbean Region Social Projection Unit . Google Scholar
G. E. Perry and W. F. Maloney , Informality: Exit and Exclusion , eds. G. E. Perry et al. ( World Bank , Washington DC , 2007 ) . Crossref, Google Scholar
A. Portes , The Handbook of Economic Sociology , eds. N. J. Smelser and R. Swedberg ( Princeton University Press , Princeton , 1994 ) . Google Scholar
Portes, A and W Haller (2004). La Economía Informal. Seria Políticas Sociales 100. División de Desarrollo Social – CEPAL. Santiago: United Nations . Google Scholar
A. Portes and B. Roberts, Studies in Comparative International Development 40(1), 43 (2005), DOI: 10.1007/BF02686288. Crossref, Google Scholar
R. Pradhan, World Development 17(1), 157 (1989), DOI: 10.1016/0305-750X(89)90228-3. Crossref, Google Scholar
C. Rakowski , Contrapunto: The Informal Sector Debate in Latin America , ed. C. A. Rakowski ( State University of New York Press , New York , 1994 ) . Google Scholar
Reynolds, PD, WD Bygrave, E Autio, LW Cox and M Hay (2003). Global Entrepreneurship Monitor 2002. Executive Report, Babson College/Ewing Marion Kauffman Foundation: London Business School . Google Scholar
P. Rodgers and C. C. Williams, International Journal of Sociology 39(2), 3 (2009), DOI: 10.2753/IJS0020-7659390200. Crossref, Google Scholar
Sassen, S (1997). Informalization in Advanced Market Economies. Issues in Development, Discussion Paper 20, Geneva: International Labor Office . Google Scholar
A. Sauvy , Le Travail Noir Et l'economie De Demain ( Calmann-Levy , Paris , 1984 ) . Google Scholar
F. Schneider , The Hidden Economy ( Edward Elgar , Cheltenham , 2008 ) . Crossref, Google Scholar
F. Schneider and C. Bajada , Size, Causes and Consequences of the Underground Economy: An International Perspective , eds. C. Bajada and F. Schneider ( Aldershot , Ashgate , 2005 ) . Google Scholar
Singh, M (2005). Meeting Basic Needs in the Informal Economy: Integrating Education and Training for Decent Work, Empowerment and Citizenship. UNESCO–UNEVCO, Technical and Vocational Education and Training Series (2), New York: Springer . Google Scholar
Small Business Council (2004). Small Business in the Informal Economy: Making the Transition to the Formal Economy. London: Small Business Council . Google Scholar
K. Staudt , Free Trade? Informal Economies at the US-Mexico Border ( Temple University Press , Philadelphia , 1998 ) . Google Scholar
A. L. Stinchcombe , Handbook of Organization , ed. J. G. March ( Rand McNally and Company , Chicago, IL , 1965 ) . Google Scholar
J. Unni and U. Rani , Informal Economy Center Stage: New Structures of Employment , eds. R. Jhabvala , R. M. Sudarshan and J. Unni ( Sage , London , 2003 ) . Google Scholar
S. A. Venkatesh , Off the Books: The Underground Economy of the Urban Poor ( Harvard University Press , Cambridge, MA , 2006 ) . Crossref, Google Scholar
V. Volkov , Violent Entrepreneurs: The use of Force in the Making of Russian Capitalism ( Cornell University Press , Ithaca, NY , 2002 ) . Google Scholar
J. W. Webbet al., Academy of Management Review 34(3), 492 (2009), DOI: 10.5465/AMR.2009.40632826. Crossref, Google Scholar
C. C. Williams , Small Business in the Informal Economy: Making the Transition to the Formal Economy — The Evidence Base ( Small Business Service , London , 2005 ) . Google Scholar
C. C. Williams, International Journal of Entrepreneurial Behaviour and Research 11, 244 (2005). Crossref, Google Scholar
C. C. Williams , The Hidden Enterprise Culture: Entrepreneurship in the Underground Economy ( Edward Elgar , Cheltenham , 2006 ) . Crossref, Google Scholar
C. C. Williams, Journal of Developmental Entrepreneurship 12(2), 239 (2007), DOI: 10.1142/S1084946707000654. Link, Google Scholar
C. C. Williams, International Journal of Gender and Entrepreneurship 1(3), 219 (2009), DOI: 10.1108/17566260910990900. Crossref, Google Scholar
C. C. Williams, International Entrepreneurship and Management Journal 5(4), 497 (2009), DOI: 10.1007/s11365-009-0125-4. Crossref, Google Scholar
C. C. Williams and J. Round, Journal of Developmental Entrepreneurship 12(1), 119 (2007), DOI: 10.1142/S1084946707000587. Link, Google Scholar
C. C. Williams and J. Round, Journal of Developmental Entrepreneurship 13(4), 445 (2008), DOI: 10.1142/S1084946708001071. Link, Google Scholar
C. C. Williams, J. Round and J. Rodgers, Journal of Developmental Entrepreneurship 14(1), 59 (2009), DOI: 10.1142/S1084946709001144. Link, Google Scholar
C. C. Williams and J. Windebank, Gender, Work and Organization 10(3), (2003). Google Scholar
Xaba, J, P Horn and S Motala (2002). Informal Sector in Sub-Saharan Africa. Working Paper on the Informal Economy No. 10, Geneva: International Labor Office . Google Scholar