Though water scarcity threats are increasing in severity across many regions of the world, allocation often remains inefficient — as in Jordan, the site of this study. One commonly discussed solution for increasing resource availability in water-scarce regions is the use of recycled wastewater for irrigation. Yet, despite significant potential benefits, an oft-cited concern with wastewater reuse is its potential impact on water quality. This paper examines the impact of this solution by exploiting a natural experiment arising from complementary infrastructure investments that introduced recycled wastewater to a new region of the Jordan Valley. We study farmer preferences for wastewater reuse, as well as farm adaptation and profitability. We find no evidence of negative impacts on farm revenues or costs over the short term, and observe signs of adaptation via the shifting of production toward less-salinity sensitive crops. Contingent valuation measures of the willingness to pay for reliable recycled water supply across newly treated and comparison areas indicate resistance to the expanded reuse of wastewater, however, which suggests that farmers may believe that this shift will entail more substantial long-term costs. Furthermore, the stated willingness to pay and short-term marginal productivity of water estimates appear unrelated. These results suggest the need for caution in interpreting short-term adaptation and preference responses to policies that substantially alter irrigation choices and behaviors, and point to the need for longer-term studies of wastewater reuse.

Keywords:

References

Abu Madi, M, O Braadbaart, R Al-Sa’ed and G Alaerts [2003] Willingness of farmers to pay for reclaimed wastewater in Jordan and Tunisia. Water Science and Technology: Water Supply, 3(4), 115–122. Crossref, Google Scholar
Acharya, G and EB Barbier [2000] Valuing groundwater recharge through agricultural production in the Hadejia-Nguru wetlands in northern Nigeria. Agricultural Economics, 22(3), 247–259. Crossref, Google Scholar
Al Qatarneh, GN, B Al Smadi, K Al-Zboon and KM Shatanawi [2018] Impact of climate change on water resources in Jordan: A case study of Azraq basin. Applied Water Science, 8(1), 50:1–50:14. Crossref, Google Scholar
Al-Karablieh, E and A Salman (2016). Water resources, use and management in Jordan: A focus on Groundwater. IWMI Project Report No. 11, Groundwater Governance in the Arab World — Taking Stock and Addressing the Challenges. Available at http://gw-mena.iwmi.org/wp-content/uploads/sites/3/2017/04/Rep.11-Water-resources-use-and-management-in-Jordan-a-focus-on-groundwater.pdf (accessed). Google Scholar
Albert, J, S Alikhan, L Etter, M Jeuland and A Wyatt (2017). Impact evaluation design report: Jordan Compact — Water sector. Submitted to the Millenium Challenge Corporation by Social Impact, Inc., December. Available at https://data.mcc.gov/evaluations/index.php/catalog/103/download/1035 (accessed). Google Scholar
Assouline, S and K Narkis [2011] Effects of long-term irrigation with treated wastewater on the hydraulic properties of a clayey soil. Water Resources Research, 47(8), W08530:1–W08530:12. Crossref, Google Scholar
Bakopoulou, S, S Polyzos and A Kungolos [2010] Investigation of farmers’ willingness to pay for using recycled water for irrigation in Thessaly region, Greece. Desalination, 250(1), 329–334. Crossref, Google Scholar
Barbier, EB [2007] Valuing ecosystem services as productive inputs. Economic Policy, 22(49), 177+179–229. Crossref, Google Scholar
Bishop, RC and KJ Boyle [2019] Reliability and validity in nonmarket valuation. Environmental and Resource Economics, 72(2), 559–582. Crossref, Google Scholar
Bouzit, M, S Das and L Cary [2018] Valuing treated wastewater and reuse: Preliminary implications from a meta-analysis. Water Economics and Policy, 4(2), 1650044. Link, Google Scholar
Cameron, TA, GL Poe, RG Ethier and WD Schulze [2002] Alternative non-market value-elicitation methods: Are the underlying preferences the same? Journal of Environmental Economics and Management, 44(3), 391–425. Crossref, Google Scholar
Cameron, TA [1992] Combining contingent valuation and travel cost data for the valuation of nonmarket goods. Land Economics, 68(3), 302–317. Crossref, Google Scholar
Cirelli, GL, S Consoli, F Licciardello, R Aiello, F Giuffrida and C Leonardi [2012] Treated municipal wastewater reuse in vegetable production. Agricultural Water Management, 104, 163–170. Crossref, Google Scholar
Connor, JD, K Schwabe, D King and K Knapp [2012] Irrigated agriculture and climate change: The influence of water supply variability and salinity on adaptation. Ecological Economics, 77, 149–157. Crossref, Google Scholar
Darwish, MR, M Sharara and B Hamdar [1999] Economic-Environmental approach for optimum wastewater utilization in irrigation: A case study in Lebanon. Applied Engineering in Agriculture, 15(1), 41–48. Crossref, Google Scholar
FAO (2016). AQUASTAT Core Database: FAO’s Global Information System on Water and Agriculture. Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations. Available at http://www.fao.org/aquastat/en/databases/maindatabase (accessed May 30, 2020). Google Scholar
Feinerman, E and Y Tsur [2014] Perennial crops under stochastic water supply. Agricultural Economics, 45(6), 757–766. Crossref, Google Scholar
Finkelshtain, I, I Kan and M Rapaport-Rom [2020] Substitutability of freshwater and non-freshwater sources in irrigation: An econometric analysis. American Journal of Agricultural Economics, 102(4), 1105–1134. Crossref, Google Scholar
Grafton, RQ, J Williams, CJ Perry, F Molle, C Ringler, P Steduto, B Udall, SA Wheeler, Y Wang and RG Allen [2018] The paradox of irrigation efficiency. Science, 361(6404), 748–750. Crossref, Google Scholar
Haruvy, N [1997] Agricultural reuse of wastewater: Nation-wide cost-benefit analysis. Agriculture, Ecosystems and Environment, 66(2), 113–119. Crossref, Google Scholar
Jeuland, M, M Pucilowski, D Hudner, A Smith, T Thompson, C Seybolt, $\dots$ and A Wyatt (2020). Impact evaluation of the MCA Jordan Compact: Endline report. Available at https://data.mcc.gov/evaluations/index.php/catalog/103 (accessed). Google Scholar
Jeuland, M [2012] Creating incentives for more effective wastewater reuse in the Middle East and North Africa. In Economic Incentives and Environmental Regulation: Evidence from the MENA Region, H Abou-Ali (ed.), pp. a–b. London: Edward Elgar. Crossref, Google Scholar
Kijne, JW [2003] Water productivity under saline conditions. In Water Productivity in Agriculture, JW Kijne, R Barker and D Molden (eds.), pp. 89–102. Colombo, Sri Lanka: International Water Management Institute. Crossref, Google Scholar
Kubursi, A, V Grover, AR Darwish and E Deutsch (2011). Water scarcity in Jordan: Economic instruments, issues and options. Working Paper No. 599, The Economic Research Forum (ERF), Giza, Egypt. Google Scholar
Levy, GJ, P Fine, D Goldstein, A Azenkot, A Zilberman, A Chazan and T Grinhut [2014] Long term irrigation with treated wastewater (TWW) and soil sodification. Biosystems Engineering, 128, 4–10. Crossref, Google Scholar
Maas, EV and SR Grattan [1999] Crop yields as affected by salinity. In Agricultural Drainage, RW Skaggs and J van Schilfgaarde (eds.), Vol. 38, pp. 55–108. Madison, WI: American Society of Agronomy. Crossref, Google Scholar
MacEwan, D, R Howitt and J Medellin-Azuara [2016] Combining physical and behavioral response to salinity. Water Economics and Policy, 2(1), 1650010. Link, Google Scholar
Martínez, S, R Suay, J Moreno and ML Segura [2013] Reuse of tertiary municipal wastewater effluent for irrigation of Cucumis melo L. Irrigation Science, 31(4), 661–672. Crossref, Google Scholar
Mekonnen, MM and YA Hoekstra [2016] Four billion people facing severe water scarcity. Science Advances, 2(1), e1500323:1–e1500323:7. Google Scholar
Ministry of Water and Irrigation of Jordan (2015). National Water Strategy 2016-2015. Available at https://web.archive.org/web/20180328180414/http://www.mwi.gov.jo/sites/en-us/Hot Issues/Strategic Documents of The Water Sector/National Water Strategy(2016-2025)-25.2.2016.pdf (accessed). Google Scholar
Ministry of Water and Irrigation of Jordan (n.d.). Ministry of Water and Irrigation: Waste Water Policy. Available at https://web.archive.org/web/20180104121225/http://www.mwi.gov.jo/sites/en-us/SitePages/WaterPolicies/WasteWaterPolicy.aspx# (accessed February 17, 2018). Google Scholar
Mustafa, D, A Altz-Stamm and LM Scott [2016] Water user associations and the politics of water in Jordan. World Development, 79, 164–176. Crossref, Google Scholar
Ndunda, EN and ED Mungatana [2013] Evaluating the welfare effects of improved wastewater treatment using a discrete choice experiment. Journal of Environmental Management, 123, 49–57. Crossref, Google Scholar
Orgill-Meyer, J, M Jeuland, J Albert and N Cutler [2018] Comparing contingent valuation and averting expenditure estimates of the costs of irregular water supply. Ecological Economics, 146, 250–264. Crossref, Google Scholar
Pattanayak, SK, JC Yang, D Whittington and KC Bal Kumar [2005] Coping with unreliable public water supplies: Averting expenditures by households in Kathmandu, Nepal. Water Resources Research, 41(2), W02012:1–W02012:11. Crossref, Google Scholar
Paudel, I, A Bar-Tal, GJ Levy, N Rotbart, JE Ephrath and S Cohen [2018] Treated wastewater irrigation: Soil variables and grapefruit tree performance. Agricultural Water Management, 204, 126–137. Crossref, Google Scholar
Reznik, A, E Feinerman, I Finkelshtain, F Fisher, A Huber-Lee, B Joyce and I Kan [2017] Economic implications of agricultural reuse of treated wastewater in Israel: A statewide long-term perspective. Ecological Economics, 135, 222–233. Crossref, Google Scholar
Reznik, A, A Dinar and F Hernández-Sancho [2019] Treated wastewater reuse: An efficient and sustainable solution for water resource scarcity. Environmental & Resource Economics, 74(4), 1647–1685. Crossref, Google Scholar
Rice, J and P Westerhoff [2015] Spatial and temporal variation in de facto wastewater reuse in drinking water systems across the U.S.A. Environmental Science and Technology, 49(2), 982–989. Crossref, Google Scholar
Rosado, MA, MA Cunha-E-Sá, MM Ducla-Soares and LC Nunes [2006] Combining averting behavior and contingent valuation data: An application to drinking water treatment in Brazil. Environment and Development Economics, 11(6), 729–746. Crossref, Google Scholar
Storey, R and RR Walker [1998] Citrus and salinity. Scientia Horticulturae, 78(1–4), 39–81. Crossref, Google Scholar
Urama, KC and ID Hodge [2006] Are stated preferences convergent with revealed preferences? Empirical evidence from Nigeria. Ecological Economics, 59(1), 24–37. Crossref, Google Scholar
Wooldridge, JM [2006] Introductory Econometrics: A Modern Approach, 3rd Ed. Mason, OH: Thomson/South-Western. Google Scholar